Wednesday, December 16, 2020

Ratings Rundown - 15th December 2020

CHASERS (125-Rated plus)

Risers (3lb+):

Name

08/12/2020

15/12/2020

Change

SKY PIRATE (GB)

134

144

10

EVANDER (IRE)

123

132

9

EARTH MOOR (IRE)

132

140

8

DUC DE GRISSAY (FR)

118

126

8

MISTER FISHER (IRE)

155

162

7

ROCKY'S TREASURE (IRE)

138

145

7

MALYSTIC (GB)

140

147

7

STORM CONTROL (IRE)

136

142

6

DEFI DES CARRES (FR)

121

127

6

VADO FORTE (FR)

128

133

5

HAPPYGOLUCKY (IRE)

142

147

5

HURRICANE HARVEY (GB)

139

144

5

NORTHOFTHEWALL (IRE)

135

140

5

DANS LE VENT (FR)

128

132

4

LIBERTY BELLA (GB)

125

129

4

GIVE ME A COPPER (IRE)

146

149

3

IBLEO (FR)

137

140

3

ARIAN (IRE)

126

129

3

MR CLARKSON (IRE)

128

131

3

ZAMBELLA (FR)

139

142

3

MASTER WORK (FR)

123

126

3

 

Where to start but with Sky Pirate? The perennial bridesmaid got his day in the sun at Cheltenham over 2 miles for the first time. Ridden confidently towards the back, he never came off the bridle to hose up by 4 lengths. The visuals merited a 10lb hike and he may be value for it while still unexposed over the minimum trip, but my suspicion is he has to win on the bridle and there wasn’t much left. Nonetheless a big field 2 mile target such as the Grand Annual would be of interest if it comes up soft but he’d have to be a 150+ horse to cope with the Irish battalions, some of whom will have been lolloping around mudbaths all winter in preparation for the Festival (looking at you, Le Richebourg). Ibleo from the same race may now be in the grip of the handicapper.

Earth Moor could be decent, but his inconsistency means the jury is out now off 140. Either way, his win paid a handsome compliment to weekend winner Happygolucky, who I suspect would be outstayed in the mooted National Hunt Chase at the Festival, but may go well in something like the Ultima off 147 as a strong traveller that gets 3 miles.

Unless he can pull off Frodon-like powers of carrying weight, Mister Fisher has surely now said goodbye to handicaps. He may snatch a place in a Grade 1 on rattling quick ground but I fancy he's found his niche in small-field Grade 2s for the time being, an able replacement at Seven Barrows for Top Notch who appears on the way out (or badly needed the run).

Storm Control had plenty left in the tank as he almost pulled himself up at Cheltenham and 7lbs seems very fair. He’s probably the type of horse who won’t sustain this form forever so don’t be surprised to see him out again early in the New Year as connections try strike again while the iron is hot.

Vado Forte beat a good yardstick Defi Sacre into third at Doncaster as well as the talented Solar Impulse who was clearly on a going day. He won with plenty in hand and 5lbs is unlikely to stop him next time if in the same mood.

3 to follow: Storm Control, Happygolucky, Vado Forte

 

Non-movers* (-2lbs to +2lbs):

Name

08/12/2020

15/12/2020

Change

MIDNIGHT SHADOW (GB)

148

149

1

BENATAR (IRE)

142

142

0

POTTERS LEGEND (GB)

135

135

0

DEFI SACRE (FR)

129

128

-1

CEPAGE (FR)

155

154

-1

* Selected horses

Despite the Caspian Caviar not looking as strong as the Paddy Power Gold Cup on paper, I’ve gone and picked three from it for this section because the race was somewhat blown apart by Chatham Street Lad. Midnight Shadow was best of the rest by a good 12 lengths and if the winner hadn’t journeyed over from Ireland may be looking at a 10lb hike rather than just the 1lb. He’s always threatened to make up into a graded performer and could make a mockery of a mark in the 140s at some point.

Benatar ran brilliantly off a massive layoff and looks to have retained most of his ability. He paid the price for his keenness (which has always been there but was surely augmented by the break) and lack of fitness. A drop in trip may be the answer anyway and 142 is likely to underestimate him, the bounce factor notwithstanding.

Cepage couldn’t raise a gallop (or a jump) which was rather surprising given his strength in the market. However, it was too bad to be true and he’s now on the mark of his last win, which came on New Year’s Day last season. Plenty more mileage there if you’re willing to forgive this aberration.

Potters Legend stays on 135, despite splitting the winner who looks on a hot streak and Court Maid who was well in. There must be more to come and soon, even with his advancing years, with plenty of staying chases to choose from in the New Year.

I thought Defi Sacre would have to be beaten by a well in horse at the weekend and there’s a chance he was still feeling the effects of a run (and fall) two weeks prior. He’s been dropped a pound now, so assuming he’s freshened up and ready to go next time, still looks ahead of the handicapper.

3 to follow: Midnight Shadow, Cepage, Potters Legend

 

Fallers (3lbs-):

Name

08/12/2020

15/12/2020

Change

DOCTOR DEX (IRE)

135

130

-5

GINO TRAIL (IRE)

147

142

-5

MILITARIAN (GB)

138

133

-5

QUEL DESTIN (FR)

152

147

-5

TOP NOTCH (FR)

158

154

-4

CANYON CITY (GB)

136

132

-4

PALMERS HILL (IRE)

137

133

-4

THEATRE LEGEND (GB)

131

128

-3

VIVAS (FR)

130

127

-3

FLOW AWAY (IRE)

131

128

-3

BOB MAHLER (IRE)

140

137

-3

BORN SURVIVOR (IRE)

145

142

-3

DRUMCONNOR LAD (IRE)

145

142

-3

HOLD THE NOTE (IRE)

143

140

-3

SINGLEFARMPAYMENT (GB)

137

134

-3

STEELY ADDITION (IRE)

140

137

-3

KILBRICKEN STORM (IRE)

135

132

-3

STORMY IRELAND (FR)

145

142

-3

UMBRIGADO (IRE)

142

139

-3

 

Palmers Hill has dropped by a massive 4lbs despite going off favourite and could well have needed the run lugging over 12 stone around Taunton. He’s now on the mark he was a close second off at Kempton in February in a typically hot handicap and, given he’s built like a brick shithouse, should find fences more to his liking than hurdles in time.

Hold The Note ran well for a long way at Cheltenham and patently didn’t get home over and extended 3 miles. He’s been dropped a further 3lbs and is now 5lbs below the mark he was a good third off at the Festival with two handicap snips in front of him. Plenty of mileage off 140 dropped back to 2 miles 4 furlongs.

A three-runner novice chase isn’t where Umbrigado is best seen to effect, judging by his Haydock effort over hurdles off 139. Back to that mark he could be a force to be reckoned with in a novices handicap chase.

3 to follow: Palmers Hill, Hold The Note, Umbrigado

 

HURDLERS (125-rated plus)

Risers (3lb+):

Name

08/12/2020

15/12/2020

Change

HISTORIC HEART (IRE)

118

131

13

MIDNIGHTREFLECTION (GB)

121

130

9

WILD MAX (GER)

138

147

9

LORD OF KERAK (GB)

122

131

9

MOUNT WINDSOR (IRE)

119

127

8

COME ON TEDDY (IRE)

127

134

7

BREFFNIBOY (FR)

122

128

6

NEWTOWN BOY (IRE)

122

128

6

THE WHITE MOUSE (IRE)

130

136

6

ADAGIO (GER)

130

136

6

MONMIRAL (FR)

137

143

6

MINELLA DRAMA (IRE)

129

134

5

DANS LE VENT (FR)

128

132

4

GET OUT THE GATE (IRE)

124

128

4

EGLANTINE DU SEUIL (FR)

143

146

3

NO COMMENT (GB)

135

138

3

 

A few juveniles to look at here and I generally find it difficult to consider their marks until the Boodles/Fred Winter. Nigel Hawke thinks otherwise and has already run Historic Heart in open handicaps, but my initial reaction is that this was a weakish race. Time will tell.

Up north, Monmiral won the Summit doing handstands despite a sizeable mistake at the second-last. For me, it was the most substantial British performance so far (make of the Nassalam efforts what you will), although Gordon Elliott would appear to have at least a couple of behemoths in this division already across the Irish Sea.

Come On Teddy looked the winner the whole way round at Cheltenham in what seemed to be a hot 3 mile handicap and a 7lb may underestimate him.

The following afternoon The White Mouse overcame the bounce factor to score and could feasibly make it a three timer off 136. She’s only been beaten once when staying up over hurdles so there’s a good chance we haven’t seen her ceiling just yet.

3 to follow: Monmiral, Come On Teddy, The White Mouse

 

Non-movers* (-2lbs to +2lbs):

Name

08/12/2020

15/12/2020

Change

HAAFAPIECE (GB)

130

132

2

MOHAAYED (GB)

141

141

0

SUMMERVILLE BOY (IRE)

156

155

-1

CLEMENCIA (IRE)

132

131

-1

* Selected horses

Haafapiece was leading and looked to have every chance when coming down and assuming he’s none the worse (best wishes with Gina Andrews who sustained some nasty injuries in the fall), should be able to make amends at some point off 2lbs higher. Clemencia was a ludicrous price (80/1) for the same race and stayed on nicely into fourth to bag each way backers a bigger return than the winner. If he steps up a few furlongs off one pound lower I’d be very keen to have him onside in a weaker race or at what is likely to be a big price.

Mohaayed stayed on nicely into third in the race won by Come On Teddy. He looks to have found a new metier over 3 miles and with his love of big field handicaps, don’t be surprised to see him attempt to gain a place in the Pertemps back at Cheltenham in March.

Only two starts ago Summerville Boy was winning a hot listed race at Aintree and since then he’s been beaten into fourth and fifth over 3 and 2 miles respectively. Neither are his trip – 2 and a half is perfect now – and even if Tom George opts to take on the Relkeel, I wonder if the Coral Cup might be of interest, a race in which those high in the weights tend to do nicely and his stamina would be seen to the fore.

3 to follow: Haafapiece, Mohaayed, Summerville Boy

 

Newbies* (new entries):

Name

15/12/2020

ANY NEWS (IRE)

142

MAKE ME A BELIEVER (IRE)

137

NASSALAM (FR)

140

* Selected horses

Make Me A Believer beat Any News one length at Cheltenham in receipt of 6lbs, so predictably he’s rated 5lbs lower. But most, including me, would be backing the former if they were to reoppose in handicap company and not just because he’s trained by a Pipe. That win screamed strongly run 2 mile handicap and, fortunately, there are plenty to choose from off 137.

Nassalam turned another low-key juvenile event into a procession and 140 is nothing but a stab in the dark by the handicapper. Not that it matters – he’ll be keeping to juvenile company for now, either following the Goshen route to the Triumph or taking in the Finale at Chepstow on the way.